firstCLUE Reviews
  • Home
  • Review Database
  • Interviews
  • Crime Fiction News
  • Submission Guidelines
  • About Us
Tag:

Mystery & Detective

Review

The Amateur

by Brian Kenney December 4, 2025

Even as a long time fan of Chris Bohjalian, whose work ranges from historical suspense to contemporary crime fiction to literary tales (and plenty else in between), I wasn’t prepared for the intensity of this story, the power of the narration, and the sheer brilliance of the book’s design. It’s 1978, and 18-year-old Mira Winston is a golf prodigy in a small, tony, Westchester town—it’s very Larchmont. Everyone, even Mira, expects that her life has been planned out for her, from Yale in a year to the LPGA after college graduation. Until a blazing-hot August morning when Mira is practicing at the local country club and drives a ball straight through the net at 150 miles per hour, slamming it into the head of high-school junior Kenny Foster, killing him immediately. A horrible accident? Yes, a horrible accident: somehow, there was a hole in the net, which allowed the ball easy passage. But as the story slowly unfolds in the months to come, and as Mira awaits trial, people’s opinion of the golfer starts to shift. Did you know Mira was having an affair with a man three decades her senior? And that Kenny’s younger sisters were consumed by grief? And that Mira has a history of recklessness, although it may be constructed? Slowly, Mira is flipped in public opinion from teen in trouble to woman in despair. But what keeps this book so honest, direct, and yes, at times, humorous is the first person voice of Mira, taking readers to another era we are unlikely to ever forget.

December 4, 2025 0 comment
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

Death and Other Occupational Hazards

by Dodie Ownes December 4, 2025

Death has gone on vacation here and there, but after she hears about a sabbatical while on a trip across the River Styx, the Boss agrees to her request for a break. Her sister Life gives her the chance to live in human form so she can understand humans better. Now Delara, working as a paralegal at a second-rate law firm in London, is shaken when she discovers an Unplanned Death caused by vampire fish—after all, it’s her department, and the Boss will not be happy if he finds out. She left the temp in charge—is that the problem? Of course, Life is all over Delara, asking how her creations could be snuffed out without regard for the Plan. The days of simply putting folks on the Boat could be over if she cannot find out how this aberration has occurred. No longer in a black sack and carrying a scythe, Delara is hot to get to the bottom of the issue when charming parasitologist Marco enters the investigation. Debut-author Dapunt fills this rollicking story with sideways glances at the afterlife, the underworld, and the Human Communications Director (HCD, aka Jesus). Beyond the central murder mystery, the novel explores themes of life and death, love and relationships, the meaning of existence, and human emotions. Satirical, funny, and packed with wry observations on how humans approach death, and life.

December 4, 2025 0 comment
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

Last Night Was Killer

by Brian Kenney November 20, 2025

Book of The Week

Interested in a new and hilarious spin on motherhood? Then get on your reading list the laugh-aloud-funny/steer-wheel-gripping story of Tilly Turner, a single mom who will do anything for her identical twin daughters. When her career as a stand-up comic hits the shredder and her beloved mother has recently died, Tilly moves back to her hometown in Idaho, eager to establish community. Which, naturally, brings her to join a pole-dancing 101 class. And guess what? Pole dancing turns out to be a total blast. If only she didn’t wake up the next morning with a pounding headache, bad case of alcohol-induced amnesia, and a dead body scrunched in the trunk of the car. For starters, who is the dead man? Could Tilly have done him in? And where can she get a reliable babysitter whom the twins will love so that she can go figure out what’s happening and what the other strippers may know? Add to this the hottie agent from the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives who keeps showing up at her home, not invited but not disinvited either. Sit back, relax, and enjoy what is sure to be one of the best blends of crime fiction with a good dollop of coziness to be published in 2026.

© 2025 firstCLUE Reviews

Subscribe to our newsletter today!

November 20, 2025 0 comment
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

The Final Problem

by Danise Hoover November 20, 2025

It’s 1960, and Ormond Basil, semi-retired actor, encounters two friends who persuade him to join them on a yacht for a brief Mediterranean jaunt, ostensibly to discuss a possible acting opportunity. Basil made his fame by playing Sherlock Holmes in 15 films, and many still think of him in that role. An unexpected storm traps the three on a small island where there’s only a hotel and restaurant, and overnight, there is a classic locked-room murder. With no authorities on the island, and only seven guests and four hotel staff, somehow Basil is charged with the investigation. A Spanish author of pot-boiler mysteries becomes his Watson, and together they mull over the clues of this and the murders that follow. Basil’s internal dialog is full of old movie gossip, and his full memorization of the Doyle oeuvre gives color to their probing. There is of course a postmortem, which offers a solution to the question of whether Holmes was faced with Moriarty or Irene Adler. A wonderful three-pipe problem with all loose ends neatly tied up.

© 2025 firstCLUE Reviews

Subscribe to our newsletter today!

November 20, 2025 0 comment
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

The Dog Walkers’ Detective Agency

by Brian Kenney November 13, 2025

A heartfelt animal cozy akin to David Rosenfeld’s Andy Carpenter series and Rita Mae Brown’s Sneaky Pie Brown books, along with all the sophistication of Only Murders in the Building. The small, coastal town of Framstone is dog heaven, with walkers providing their pooches with rural strolls, treats galore, and smells most intriguing. Until Charles Boardman is dragged deep into the woods by Ruby, his Staffordshire bull terrier. Has Ruby found a half-eaten burger? Try the corpse of a former cop who now owns a bar. It takes only milliseconds for the information to spread among the dog-walking community, with mid-thirtyish Charlie—who grew up in Framstone and has only recently returned—at the center of the investigation. But the story doesn’t end there. Charlie receives anonymous threats, and, even more frightening, another body surfaces on the beach. Can Charlie resolve the mystery and come out alive? Hogan’s prose is delightful, full of humor and wonderfully clever. This reader’s only wish is that this book is the first in a series.

© 2025 firstCLUE Reviews

Subscribe to our newsletter today!

November 13, 2025 0 comment
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

Lost in Yellowstone

by Jeff Ayers November 13, 2025

pecial Agent Emme Helliwell of the National Park Service ends up in Yellowstone to investigate when a human foot is found after the eruption of a geyser in Maggi’s follow-up to A Death in Zion. Going back to this historic National Park brings excessive stress and concern, since her last time there, she failed to find missing hiker David Finch. If the foot is David’s, it will solve a three-year-old cold case. Unfortunately, the coroner determines that the foot comes from a teenager, not an adult. Helliwell discovers a mysterious private school called Higher Purpose, and everything about its operations seems sketchy. Add in an ex-boyfriend ranger to assist her on the case; since their breakup didn’t end well, the stress levels for Helliwell guarantee that at some point she will explode like Old Faithful. Maggi uses the natural, chaotic Yellowstone landscape in an imaginative, fun way to tell her terrific story. Readers who love the National Parks will find much to savor and will want to visit Yellowstone right after turning the last page.

© 2025 firstCLUE Reviews

Subscribe to our newsletter today!

November 13, 2025 0 comment
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

Ruby Falls

by Dodie Ownes November 13, 2025

Times are hard everywhere in 1928, but when Leo Lambert discovers a huge underground waterfall in a cave system outside Chattanooga, he is convinced it can be a moneymaker and names it after his wife, Ruby. There are curiosity seekers, but Ruby Falls needs something sensational to bring the crowds and their coins to town. Enter Professor Jeremiah Hagathorn, known all over the Midwest for his mind-reading skills, whom Leo challenges to find a hatpin hidden somewhere in the six miles of caves around Ruby Falls. With a small entourage in tow, including a newspaper reporter and Hagathorn’s wife, Editha, Hagathorn embarks on his mission. Unbeknownst to the group, Quinton, a cave guide, and Ada, a recent widower who has been secretly roaming the caves, have been charged with following the professor and others to ensure their safety. When the reporter is found dead after their first night in the caves, Hagathorn insists on continuing his quest before returning to the surface to report the murder, despite knowing that the killer is among them. No one is to be trusted, and as supplies dwindle, suspicions grow. Phillips gives readers two stories here—the sensational hatpin search amidst the danger and grandeur of Ruby Falls, and Ada’s grieving for a life never lived, not knowing about the one that lies before her. A historical mystery in a unique setting, adding “locked cave” to the genre vernacular.

© 2025 firstCLUE Reviews

Subscribe to our newsletter today!

November 13, 2025 0 comment
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

A Whiff of Murder

by Danise Hoover November 13, 2025

In a historic house in Astoria, OR lives Lise, who can scent emotion, and sometimes history; Fran, who can hear the spirits of the house talking; and Theodora, or Teddy, owner of the house and former muse to rock stars. The house itself accepts or rejects new renters, and though economics necessitates another housemate, the house so far has not found anyone acceptable. Lise, clerk in a shop that sells crystals, potions, tarot cards, and the like, finds her boss dead the morning after she submits her resignation, and the police officer who responds is a nemesis from her earlier years in Seattle. The three women, unsatisfied with the quick dismissal of the death as coming from natural causes, set out to find the truth. Their methods are creative, exciting, and somewhat dangerous. Our trio has intriguing backstories, and the adjunct characters that assist along the way are a wonderful addition to the cast. This is the first of a promised series from the author of another witchy Oregon series (the Witch Way Librarian books) and readers will look forward eagerly to the next installment.

© 2025 firstCLUE Reviews

Subscribe to our newsletter today!

November 13, 2025 0 comment
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

A Bad, Bad Place

by Henrietta Thornton November 6, 2025

Fierce love from her grandmother and friendship with sweet sidekick Martin is barely enough to keep lonely Janey going. Her parents and older sister died in a Glasgow council-flat gas explosion. Granny’s doing her best ever since, but 12-year-old Janey is again pushed to the emotional brink when she finds the dead body of a young woman, Samantha, when walking badly behaved, marvelously named dog Sid Vicious. Janey did something—readers don’t know what—when she found the body, and she’s terrified that the police will find out. Still more terrifying is the local thug who’s the dead girl’s father, not to mention his violent minions who seem to show up everywhere Janey goes. There’s a glossary at book’s end explaining Glaswegian slang that’s used throughout the book, but the usage is understandable in context. It creates an immersive, chilly atmosphere for Janey’s desperate digging into who the killer is and how to get back to quiet life with Granny, Sid Vicious, and goofy, funny Martin. Love and Janey’s innocence and smarts make this a novel to remember. It’s a gem on its own, but you can also use the book as a primer for Callum McSorley’s Glasgow-gritty Squeaky Clean.

© 2025 firstCLUE Reviews

Subscribe to our newsletter today!

 

November 6, 2025 0 comment
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

The Kindness of Strangers

by Brian Kenney November 6, 2025

42 Tregunter Road in Chelsea is a sort of glamorous boarding (glamboarding?) house, crowded with quite the menagerie of residents. In this classic golden-age murder mystery set just in post-World War II England—chocolate is finally no longer rationed—it’s a stranger’s arrival that sets the story into motion. The old Victorian houses the owner, Mrs. Honor Wilson, a Bohemian who publishes a literary journal; writer Robbie; Mina, would-be detective; debutante George; and Saul, who would like to forget his refugee past. Then into the cozy home arrives Jimmy Sullivan, whose presence sets everyone else atwitter, and who smoothly moves into the attic (Honor claims he is a friend of the family. No one believes her). From there the story really takes off as Jimmy’s secrets, lies, and schemes come tumbling out, leaving one of the group most resolutely dead. A delightful period piece as sophisticated as it is humorous.

November 6, 2025 0 comment
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • …
  • 54

Get the Newsletter

Recent Posts

  • Thirty Feet Under: A Mystery
  • The Spies of Hartlake Hall
  • Mr. and Mrs. Dixon Hide a Body
  • The Model Patient
  • Imposter

Recent Comments

No comments to show.

About Us

firstCLUE© aspires to publish the first reviews of today's most intriguing crime fiction. Founded by Brian Kenney and Henrietta Verma, two librarians who are former editors at Library Journal and School Library Journal.

Our Most Read Reviews

  • 1

    The Murder of Mr. Ma

    October 12, 2023
  • 2

    Murder by the Seashore

    April 6, 2023
  • 3

    The Road to Murder

    July 27, 2023

Get the Newsletter

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Email

©Copyright 2024, firstCLUE - All Right Reserved.


Back To Top
firstCLUE Reviews
  • Home
  • Review Database
  • Interviews
  • Crime Fiction News
  • Submission Guidelines
  • About Us