firstCLUE Reviews
  • Home
  • Review Database
  • Interviews
  • Crime Fiction News
  • Submission Guidelines
  • About Us
Tag:

Historical

Article

Murder on 34th Street

by Willy Williams August 27, 2026

Book of the Week August 27, 2026

It’s a chill November afternoon in 1932, the day before the ninth annual Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade. Grace Verlander, the assistant to the store’s head of personnel, receives a note from Santa Claus saying that his life has been threatened. Who would want to kill jolly old St. Nick, or rather, gentle, sixty-ish Harry Gardner, who works in children’s shoes? Having been put in charge of talent for the parade and having cast Harry in the iconic role, Grace must now ensure his safety and enlists the head of store security, Frank Halsey, to protect Harry. Unfortunately, at the end of the parade, Halsey is found shot to death in the workshop on Santa’s float, and Grace turns store detective to identify the killer. Fredericks’ fourth historical standalone after The Girl in the Green Dress is a holiday charmer, mixing fascinating, immersive behind-the-scenes details about the world’s largest department store (the author did her homework!) with a vintage New York Christmas atmosphere and a touch of romance. Grace is a fantastic protagonist: whip-smart, funny, and empathetic, she passionately loves her job and her Macy’s coworkers. Readers may also want to rewatch Fredericks’s obvious inspiration, the classic 1947 film Miracle on 34th Street.—Willy Williams

August 27, 2026 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

The Christmas Clue

by Dodie Ownes August 27, 2026

The Second World War is grinding on, and it’s hard for anyone in Britain to be particularly cheerful this Christmas. Anthony and Elva Pratt will do their best to rise above the melancholy and give the guests at Tudor Close, an elegant hotel that has seen better days, a murder-mystery game that will puzzle and thrill. Before they ever reach their destination, the Pratts discover the body of Miss Silver, a local shopkeeper with deep roots in the village. Upon arrival at the hotel, they find guests Professor Rivers and his wife, former occupants of the building when it was a private home, arguing with manager Reg Browning over a room change. Tensions are running high, and the Pratts are not sure they will be able to pull off their planned mystery. Sharp observers, they quickly begin to question the Rivers’ intentions and the secrecy of the staff—and then another murder takes place, this time of Reverend Green, bludgeoned with a candlestick! Upson gives readers a clever locked-hotel mystery with relevant historical and social details woven into the plot and a final twist that may elicit a gasp. Any similarity to the game Clue™ is not accidental, as the real-life Pratts created the game Cluedo™, as it is known in the UK, in 1947! Best read during a snowstorm with a glass of sherry at hand.—Dodie Ownes

August 27, 2026 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

Dark Messiah

by Henrietta Thornton August 20, 2026

Book of the Week August 20, 2026

How smart people can allow themselves to be lured into a cult and the evils that charismatic men can convince followers to accept are laid bare on the pages of Carson’s psychedelically violent debut, set in the mid 1970s. Faye Sterling is embarrassed to come from big-time money, and when a religious leader known as Dad to his followers offers her the chance at authenticity by joining his group, she jumps at it. Her neglect and fervor force her teenage daughter, Nell, our narrator, from San Francisco to a supposed utopian compound in South America. The Jim Jones parallels are obvious and all too accurate. Dad, “a combination of Revered King, Angela Davis, and Albert Einstein,” just cares so much that he violently abuses his followers, even children, so that they can improve their behavior. Behind closed doors, his sex with Nell and other young women “helps them to detach from the shame that they feel in their bodies.” These abuses, and verbal viciousness including Dad’s repeated use of the n-word, are very much on the page, creating a feeling of hurtling toward disaster. Outside forces loom large in the end—some real, such as Nell’s actual father’s desperation to get her out, some exaggerated by Dad, including his news about the scary, threatening outside world. An absorbing, shocking first from Carson.—Henrietta Thornton

August 20, 2026 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

Cold Sunset

by Dodie Ownes July 30, 2026

Life is good for travel writer Gabriel Dax—his books are doing well, and he’s enjoying time in London and his country cottage planning his next title. But when MI6 handler Faith Green informs him that he is needed, this time to get a double agent out of Russia, he brushes off his passport and takes orders. Using his artifice skills (he thinks) to avoid confrontations with Russians, or maybe the Mafia or an insider, Dax skips from the UK to the U.S, Russia, and Finland, with some stops in between during Cold War 1964, an intriguing period in international espionage. I fell for Dax immediately—he’s a Gitane chain smoker, a low-key intellectual, and still a bit naive on how all these spying things work. And he doesn’t mind the attention of dangerous women who may or may not be trying to kill him. Boyd builds this smart tale with a delicious push and pull to the storyline, teasing readers who are trying to work out who will be taken out next. We even get to sit in on Dax’s therapy sessions! It’s easy to drop into this thriller, even though it’s the third in the series. After meeting Gabriel Dax, though, you may want to go back to the beginning; Gabriel’s Moon is the first book in the series and after that is The Predicament.—Dodie Ownes

July 30, 2026 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

The Whitechapel Full Moon Society

by Willy Williams May 28, 2026

On September 11, 1888, a few days after Jack the Ripper’s second victim was found brutally murdered, a desperate Caroline Foster arrives in London with only a battered steamer trunk and five shillings in her purse. Forced to sell her deceased father’s estate to settle his debts, Caroline is now homeless. Her only hope is to find her estranged brother, Charlie, whose last known address is 212 Montague Street in London’s notorious Whitechapel district. What she finds is a disreputable gentlemen’s boarding house, the Whitechapel Full Moon Society, but no Charlie, who vanished in June. With nowhere else to go, Caroline applies for the open maid’s position. Mrs. Easton, the landlady, gives her three rules: ask no personal questions of the guests, never enter the iron-barred room on the second floor, and, most importantly, remain locked in her room during the night of the full moon. As Caroline adjusts to her daily tasks, she begins to suspect that this strange house and its odd residents might be connected to her brother’s disappearance and the serial killings terrorizing London. Writing with verve and flair, DeLozier, in her sophomore outing (after Eleanore of Avignon), offers a fresh take on the Jack the Ripper mythos and adds a paranormal twist. Following Caroline’s transformation from a sickly, timid young woman into a strong, confident protagonist who discovers her true identity and takes charge of her life is a compelling and delightful journey. Fans of historical fantasy mysteries with a touch of dark romance will adore this one.—Willy Williams

May 28, 2026 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

The Parisian Heist

by Henrietta Thornton April 2, 2026

Book of the Week 4.2.26

The catalyst for the action, emotions, and treachery in this book is the desperation of widow Jo van Gogh. Her brother-in-law Vincent’s work is now beloved and fetches millions, but after he and Jo’s husband Theo were gone, Jo was left with little except the determination to make Vincent famous. For years, she begged dealers and galleries to just take a chance on the work they deemed “a bit hectic.” Jo became like the other women who form the backbone of this twisting thriller: underestimated by men but never by one another, while saving their lives by their wiles and willingness to disregard convention. The savvy widow is aided in her work by Claire, a former sex worker with many secrets who’s desperate that Jo won’t find out a truth about her earlier life, and who makes a decision that threatens to destroy her present as well. Those women’s drama intertwines with chapters that take place in the 1990s and feature three young women, Paris art students whose mysterious benefactor has cancelled their scholarship and who also find desperation pushing them toward actions they thought they’d never consider. At the behest of another widow, this one married into a fabulously wealthy but miserable family of art dealers, they risk everything. What a cocktail of art history, determination, and rich people behaving badly, with all capped by an art heist that will have readers holding their breaths.—Henrietta Thornton

April 2, 2026 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Article

Duel of Beasts

by Jeff Ayers March 12, 2026

What starts as a simple mission quickly turns deadly in the Morrisons’ latest chronicle of the life of excommunicated knight Gerard Fox and his wife, Willa. They want to deliver news to noblewoman Madelena about her brother’s death, but others want to keep her from learning the truth as long as they can. Madelena’s sister-in-law, Helvira, plans to seize power once her husband passes away. She’s having a secret affair with the Vizier Nayar, and a letter Gerard and Willa are planning to deliver reveals Nayar’s treachery with Helvira. If the truth of their affair were discovered, it would get them killed, so the two of them will do anything to stop Willa and Gerard from revealing the truth to Madelena. The Vizier has a collection of wild animals he uses to take out his enemies, and if Gerard and Willa are not careful, they will end up on the menu. Spain in the 1350s comes to glorious life in this non-stop action adventure, and the combination of history, culture, and romance will satisfy any reader who enjoys a great, suspenseful read. Though it’s the fourth in the series, it’s not necessary to have read the previous three to dig this one. But you’ll want to get them after finishing Duel of Beasts. Just stay away from the animal cages.—Jeff Ayers

March 12, 2026 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

The Fourth Wife

by Dodie Ownes March 12, 2026

Hazel Russon’s life in 1882 Utah territory is defined by three things: the Mormon church, polygamy, and the men, who call themselves priests and bishops, who control both. She knows she’s supposed to suppress her sinful dreams of a monogamous life with her sweetheart and her desire for the freedom to play her beloved piano. But she must, and becoming the fourth wife of Jacob Manwaring, she’s carted far away from her home, family, and civilization. Her new homestead is shared with strangers: Sister Prudence, the most recent; Sister Abby, first wife; and Sister Flora, second wife. Federal agents are pursuing polygamists, so the family must be careful how and where they are seen. When Hazel senses something shifting in the house—the actual building— her fears about being a sister wife ratchet up. Jacob, who promised her a piano, now says they don’t have one—but what about the box piano she finds in the attic? She sees apparitions, but the only one that acknowledges them is one of the children. And who is the seemingly cursed woman, and why will the others not speak of it? And is Hazel really only the fourth wife? Hamilton, a historian specializing in Mormon women in polygamy, drew inspiration from her polygamous ancestors to create this horror story grounded in historical reality. Mormon gothic at its finest.—Dodie Ownes

March 12, 2026 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

The Silent House of Sleep

by Danise Hoover March 5, 2026

Book of the Week March 5, 2026

It is 1928 when we meet highly respected pathologist Dr Jack Cuthbert. In a deft combination of mystery and history we follow him from his early days as a medical student to his time in the trenches of WWI and on to his present position of respect and authority. He faces a case that’s a true puzzler: two naked bodies buried together, tied facing each other, but with different times and methods of death. The narration takes readers back and forth in time, from Cuthbert’s war and medical-school experience to his present-day 1928, establishing the basis for the nuances of the characters. Cuthbert’s young assistant, Morgenthal, and a contentious-at-first police inspector, Mowbray, form the team that must sort out the murders, with an unlikely clue coming from Virgil. The author gives us an unvarnished view of the trenches, the social constraints of the times, and the early days of forensic medicine. This is the first in a trilogy, which was published in the UK in 2023 and won a Bloody Scotland Debut Prize, is an exceptional addition to the genre. —Danise Hoover

March 5, 2026 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

The Oxford Guide to Scandal and Lies

by Brian Kenney February 10, 2026

A delightful take on espionage fiction, laced liberally with wit, mystery, romance, and a bit of Muriel Spark. It’s 1951, and England is busy putting itself back together, from physical infrastructure to its notorious class system. The setting is Oxford, where we are introduced to two students who couldn’t be more unalike: Honorable Ginevra Bishop (destined to wear red lipstick and earn top marks) and Sidney Braithwaite (from a mining family and now a war veteran who wants a successful career). The two are brilliant at ignoring each other, but M15 has its ways, and soon enough Gin and Sidney are working together to track down a poison victim and seek out a Soviet spy. Who could be next? While there is plenty of antipathy between the two, there’s also quite a bit of romantic tension, which rears itself from times to time. For fans of historical cozies and fun-yet-frightening spy capers.—Brian Kenney

February 10, 2026 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • …
  • 14

Subscribe to the firstCLUE Reviews newsletter published weekly on Thursday, for our reviews of the newest in adult and YA crime fiction!

Subscribe Now

Recent Posts

  • Winter Song
  • Darling, You’re Next
  • The Daughter
  • The Murder Party
  • Heavy Sugar

Recent Comments

No comments to show.

About Us

firstCLUE© aspires to publish the first reviews of today's most intriguing crime fiction. Founded by Brian Kenney and Henrietta Verma, two librarians who are former editors at Library Journal and School Library Journal.

Our Most Read Reviews

  • 1

    The Murder of Mr. Ma

    October 12, 2023
  • 2

    Murder by the Seashore

    April 6, 2023
  • 3

    The Road to Murder

    July 27, 2023

Subscribe to the firstCLUE Reviews newsletter published weekly on Thursday, for our reviews of the newest in adult and YA crime fiction!

Subscribe Now

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Email

©Copyright 2024, firstCLUE - All Right Reserved.


Back To Top
firstCLUE Reviews
  • Home
  • Review Database
  • Interviews
  • Crime Fiction News
  • Submission Guidelines
  • About Us