firstCLUE Reviews
  • Home
  • Review Database
  • Interviews
  • Crime Fiction News
  • Submission Guidelines
  • About Us
Tag:

Occult & Supernatural

Review

The Wild Beneath

by Dodie Ownes June 25, 2026

Book of the Week June 25, 2026

A massive tsunami hits the Pacific Northwest and sweeps away Annie’s mother and father Maya and Aiden, and there’s not much left of Hale’s Landing, where she is sheltering with her grandmother Ruth. Then Annie discovers a man on the beach, about her age, with slimy, pale skin and strange eyes. As she and her aunt nurse Walker back to health, more questions than answers come up about him, making the townspeople suspicious. Moving back and forth in time from when Aiden first met Maya to the present to time in between, readers will find the lives of of Hale’s Landing inhabitants unfolding across the pages—Annie’s best friend and first love, Evan Hale, trapped by his father Isaac’s logging business; Uncle Henry, gruff and loving; and the chorus, locals who mistrusted Maya even before she and Aiden made the decision to live full-time on a sailboat. Annie can no longer deny that the sea calls her, as it did her mother, and Walker is somehow part of that—but how, and why? What is the connection she is missing? And can Hale’s Landing survive without the logging business that built it? Anderson spins an enchanting and exhilarating tale that will especially appeal to those who love everything about our waters and forests and all that dwell in and around them.—Dodie Ownes

June 25, 2026 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

House of Margins

by Dodie Ownes April 2, 2026

South African author Tsamaase wickedly combines the Western-horror haunted-house trope with non-Western context, infusing House of Margins with cultural symbolism and myth while drawing on Indigenous folklore and historical traumas. The book follows emerging author Anaya Sebeya, who has been invited to a prestigious residency at Günter Huis, an eerie colonial mansion on the slopes of Devil’s Peak, where she and four other emerging writers are competing for a grand prize. Being in the mansion inflicts distorted visions and terrible supernatural visitations, pushing Anaya to tell a story no one else dares to tell. Alternating chapters present Anaya’s story and that of her sister Ranewa, who searches for Anaya after she goes missing when the annual Günter Huis Fellowship is awarded, and shockingly, one of the competitors, Miche, launches a true-crime podcast about Anaya’s disappearance. The writing is tense and gives the immersive feeling of being trapped in a nightmare, intertwined with themes of abuse, colonialism, cultural appropriation, and spiritualism. The format combines Miche’s podcasts with Ranewa’s investigation, which jumpstarts when Ranewa discovers her sister’s long lost cell phone on her bed, still charged and sending messages. Readers will unravel as Anaya does, doubting what is true and who and what can be saved—this Afrofuturistic gothic horror story is full of keen observations on how postcolonial racism and the erasure of African culture are still in effect today.—Dodie Ownes

April 2, 2026 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

The Whisper

by Henrietta Thornton March 26, 2026

Four girls in each generation inherit the spell book and the secrets of magic and witchcraft in the mountain town of Whisper Ridge. Sophie, Joey, Quinn, and Elena were the chosen ones 15 years ago. Fascinated and thrilled by their new abilities, they magically hid a trail among Aspens on the edge of town and used their secret place to practice their skills. Everything fell apart when Quinn was found dead, with only Joey staying in town and dedicating herself to investigating her friend’s death—an investigation that locals think is unnecessary given that the police say Joey died accidentally. Now, curiosity and a film being shot in town have drawn Sophie and Elena back, and the three are forced to confront what really happened and how small-town dynamics can cement both love and toxicity. The magical element stays mostly in the background here but adds an unusual and absorbing twist to the rural whodunit. Still more interesting is how Iversen pits an ancient force against modern dangers to great effect. A chilling friendship tale whose ending readers won’t see coming.—Henrietta Thornton

March 26, 2026 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

The Fourth Wife

by Dodie Ownes March 12, 2026

Hazel Russon’s life in 1882 Utah territory is defined by three things: the Mormon church, polygamy, and the men, who call themselves priests and bishops, who control both. She knows she’s supposed to suppress her sinful dreams of a monogamous life with her sweetheart and her desire for the freedom to play her beloved piano. But she must, and becoming the fourth wife of Jacob Manwaring, she’s carted far away from her home, family, and civilization. Her new homestead is shared with strangers: Sister Prudence, the most recent; Sister Abby, first wife; and Sister Flora, second wife. Federal agents are pursuing polygamists, so the family must be careful how and where they are seen. When Hazel senses something shifting in the house—the actual building— her fears about being a sister wife ratchet up. Jacob, who promised her a piano, now says they don’t have one—but what about the box piano she finds in the attic? She sees apparitions, but the only one that acknowledges them is one of the children. And who is the seemingly cursed woman, and why will the others not speak of it? And is Hazel really only the fourth wife? Hamilton, a historian specializing in Mormon women in polygamy, drew inspiration from her polygamous ancestors to create this horror story grounded in historical reality. Mormon gothic at its finest.—Dodie Ownes

March 12, 2026 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

All Her Ghosts

by Dodie Ownes February 26, 2026

Prith’s YA debut is set in a world where the dead have lived alongside the living for nearly 20 years. Persephone Green is 17 years old, and her whole life people have been talking about the mysterious Ghost Wars. She and her mother, Chloe, move every few years, always suddenly, making Persephone the weird new kid at school over and over again. Chloe spends all her time in a locked laboratory with strange equipment and warning systems and refuses to discuss her work, even when alarms start going off. When Persephone meets Sebastian, something pulls her to him, and they recognize that they share one very unusual trait: neither has a heartbeat. When ghost swarms begin to grow and threaten to overtake their high school, the two decide it is time to find out who, and what, they are. The teens light out for the secret and now deserted facility that may hold the truth, pursued by Chloe, the military, and ghosts, as well as Sebastian’s friend Cain, who seems to know a lot more about Persephone than she does. This genre blender will appeal to teens who share feelings of alienation, distrust of adults, and love a good conspiracy tale—with spirits!—Dodie Ownes

February 26, 2026 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

Unnamed Bones

by Dodie Ownes January 29, 2026

Harrow Lane is 16 years old, and frankly, a mess. It doesn’t help that her mysterious hometown, Seeker’s Rest, seems to morph its landscape at will—a mountain that suddenly appears, a lake that shouldn’t be there, and a new island that shouldn’t have old-growth trees on it. Why doesn’t anyone else find this odd? Don’t they remember when those people disappeared in the lake? Considered an outsider, Harrow is surprised that when she announces she is going to explore the island, her ex-best friend and others want to join the expedition. As readers get to know Harrow, they may recognize that she is experiencing dissociative identity disorder; she has built a motel in her mind that houses Guilt, Fear, Hope, and other feelings. Her mental health struggles intertwine with the horror that waits on the island—trees that attack, water that poisons, a killer fungus—and as the group attempts to escape, their chances of survival dwindle, as do their numbers. Only when Harrow confronts her emotions is she able to see the clear path, but will the monstrous terror this island holds let them go? Themes of grief, isolation, and loneliness, as truly experienced by these trapped teens, will resonate with both young adult and adult readers.—Dodie Ownes

January 29, 2026 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

She Made Herself a Monster

by Dodie Ownes December 11, 2025

Book of the Week 12.11.25

When Kiril returns to his village of Koprivci after getting medical training in the city, he is struck once again how superstition and the Captain, the man who adopted him, control the townspeople. Preparing to set up a practice in town, he feels betrayed by Anka, his adopted sister; and friends Margarita and Simeon, who are betrothed. And Anka, just 16, will be married to the Captain as soon as she begins to menstruate, which only her caretaker Yulia can help her hide. An eviscerated chicken is found on the church steps and blood is found in eggs, all terribly bad signs for a village that is already known to be cursed. When Yana, a vampire hunter and seer, arrives, the Captain sets her the task of finding a cause for all the misfortune. Who, or what, is responsible? Could it be the pregnant widow Nina, whose husband, the village smithy, was killed by a blow from the Captain’s horse? Or maybe the Devil himself? Anka is seeking a purpose, and believes Yana can provide her with it, if she can escape the Captain. This heady Gothic debut dabbles in witchcraft and superstition while still tackling themes of betrayal and domestic abuse, weaving in stories from Slavic folklore. Eerie, haunting, and captivating.

December 11, 2025 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

You Did Nothing Wrong

by Henrietta Thornton November 13, 2025

BOOK OF THE WEEK

“In dance, there is a carnivorous demand for repetition until perfection is reached.” God knows former ballerina Elodie has put the work in, but try as she might, her life is still a mess. After a whirlwind romance, she and her six-year-old son, Jude, have moved from Australia to the States and are now living in her new husband, Bren’s, inherited house. Bren is lovingly, painstakingly, restoring the house. But its run-down, construction-site state is far from the worst problem. Elodie is already at her wit’s end with Jude’s clingy behavior and tantrums that make him seem much younger than his age. She does her best to hide his issues from Bren, but can’t keep them a secret when Jude becomes terrified of the house, which he says doesn’t want them there and has an evil life inside its walls. Events start to make Elodie agree, and once she faces “a dark that picks its teeth with children’s bones,” readers will wonder who’s right—ever-more-terrified Elodie or fed-up, it’s-all-in-your-head Bren—and how this strange domestic puzzle can ever be worked out. A chilly, creepy, gripping tale by the award-winning author of Hazelthorn.

© 2025 firstCLUE Reviews

Subscribe to our newsletter today!

November 13, 2025 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

Undead and Unwed

by Dodie Ownes August 21, 2025

Tiffenie is a 300-year old-vampire forced to live within the existence of Tiffany Amanda Blair, whose identity she recently purchased online. You see, this is a very modern vampire story. Undead and Unwed is set in dozens of Hallmark movie tropes—The Fixer Upper, The Perfect Snowy Date, The Bachelor Auction —in a small Vermont town where Tiffany has just inherited a dilapidated country house. But why now, and where is the real Tiffany? Having just lost her job at the plasma bank, Tiffenie picks up and moves with her roommate and newly minted vampire, Heaven, to Valentine to start new lives. Drinking coconut water instead of blood works, to some extent, but a gal can get thirsty, and when handsome Christmas-tree farmer Tyrone appears on the scene, Tiff’s undead body gets hot. Her irksome and devastatingly handsome ex Vlad keeps showing up, offering her eternal princesshood at his side, and decides to stay in Valentine. Everyone in town knows more about Tiffany Amanda Blair than Tiffenie does, and there is the matter of her ex-fiancé’s untimely death and his connection to Tyrone. Tiff’s sessions with the town therapist, during which she tries to convince Dr. Rosetti that she is an actual vampire, are hilarious. When the town inspector threatens to condemn the house that Tiff and Heaven plan to turn into a B&B, he suffers a regrettable injury and starts to dig deeper into Tiffany Amanda Blair. Blackmail, small-town minds, and mean girls meet found family, true love, and Hallmark happiness in this campy, little-bit-steamy, and entertaining tale.

August 21, 2025 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

Breathe In, Bleed Out

by Dodie Ownes July 17, 2025

Maybe Hannah’s best friend Tess is right—a restorative yoga retreat in Joshua Tree might be what Hannah needs to let go of the images of her fiancé’s horrific death, right after he proposed to her in a stunning wilderness setting. On the women’s arrival in the desert, all seems idyllic—the sound bowls, Guru Pax in his flowing robes, the yurts and tech-free environment. But soon Hannah’s nightmares about Ben’s death are supplemented with visions of Waylon Barlow, an ancient miner with a flesh mask and a pick axe. The other retreat attendees, including Hannah’s high school ex-boyfriend Miles; tech-bro Jared and his ethereal partner, Luna; and Dennings, an ex-Marine, start to sense that something is off. Pax’s assistant, Kimi, assures them all is well—but then Dennings disappears. In superb Final Girl form, the retreat attendees get picked off one at a time, in entertainingly gruesome ways. As Hannah struggles to survive and save Tess, she has to confront her own secrets. Author McAuley, winner of Esquire’s Best Horror Book of 2022, Curse of the Reaper, demonstrates once again his flair for cinematic suspense with humor and splatter.

July 17, 2025 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
  • 1
  • 2

Subscribe my Newsletter for new blog posts. Stay updated from your inbox!

Recent Posts

  • The Crying Killer
  • The Amateur
  • Members Only
  • Murder Unabridged
  • The Wild Beneath

Recent Comments

No comments to show.

About Us

firstCLUE© aspires to publish the first reviews of today's most intriguing crime fiction. Founded by Brian Kenney and Henrietta Verma, two librarians who are former editors at Library Journal and School Library Journal.

Our Most Read Reviews

  • 1

    The Murder of Mr. Ma

    October 12, 2023
  • 2

    Murder by the Seashore

    April 6, 2023
  • 3

    The Road to Murder

    July 27, 2023

Subscribe my Newsletter for new blog posts. Stay updated from your inbox!

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Email

©Copyright 2024, firstCLUE - All Right Reserved.


Back To Top
firstCLUE Reviews
  • Home
  • Review Database
  • Interviews
  • Crime Fiction News
  • Submission Guidelines
  • About Us