DeWitt Medical School has a drug problem. In recent years, students have overdosed, a history that students are very aware of. This year’s newbies just know they’d never do drugs, even to cope with the ultra-high pressure anatomy class that’s the center of their first-year fears. Heather is the first we spend time with. She’s trying so hard in the class but can’t seem to succeed. She sees her roommate hanging out and having a good time; surely she can’t be getting good grades from tough Dr. Conlon? As the chapters fly by, the pressure increases and we meet other students, each with pressures to bear in addition to the anatomy hell they’re enduring: a father who died too soon; tuition bills that necessitate a sketchy job that turns out much worse than expected; a famous surgeon to live up to. When the students start to crack and behave in increasingly unhinged ways, readers will be rapt and shocked by the twists revealed. Medicine is here a much more prominent element than in McFadden’s previous books, but as a former physician, she has the background to back it up. What’s no different is the stellar dark psychological suspense and characterization. Get this on your TBR.—Henrietta Thornton
Review
It’s everyone’s worst nightmare: waking up in a strange room, with injuries, a new name and hair color, and being told by an undercover cop that you are in a witness-protection program. Academic criminologist April can’t remember anything that has happened for the last several months. All Hollister, the cop, can fill her in on is that bad folks are looking for her, and if she can’t remember what how occurred before she was brought into the ER with a bullet in her head, the case against her attackers won’t fly. Bit by bit, conflicting memories come back—a fiancé, Chris, who secretly put a tracking device in her purse; a room full of bodies and red threads coming down on her; her Aunt Dahlia, who raised April after her parents and brother were killed in a car accident. Quinn (The Bridesmaid) spools out small details that build the story and keep readers guessing about Chris’s possible involvement with the mob, April’s mysterious injuries, and secrets about her family. As the trial grows near, the pressure for memories to return mounts, as does the speed and pace of the book. Triggered by flashbacks, April’s recollections begin to unravel and a desperate cross-country race to get to the evidence ensues. Quinn has built a breathless cinematic psychological thriller that leans into dissociative identity disorder, with revenge and subterfuge on the front burners.—Dodie Ownes
Emerald Lodge was bought by Jane Weber’s grandparents and she’s summered at the lake house all her life. Now she’s in her 80s, enjoying the relative peace with grandchildren underfoot, when one of them brings home what is clearly a human bone. Found on the lakeshore, it dredges up a past Jane thought she’d gotten away with. It also brings readers back to Jane’s early years at Emerald Lake, when her genteel-sleaze stepfather took advantage of powerless locals to enrich himself while they fell further into poverty. As chapters alternate perspectives between Jane and Officer Mundy, the steely woman who sees through Jane’s forgetful-old-lady facade, readers are taken on a tour of the gentrifying past meeting the present while generational secrets slowly unfurl. Prose has taken quite a detour here from her Maid books, but the same steely eye for character and spot-on inner voices remain. One for fans of Jodi Picoult and Barbara Kingsolver.—Henrietta Thornton
Book of the Week October 1, 2026
A man is found dead in his home, his body devoured by some kind of animal. Bank surveillance footage from nearby captures what looks unmistakably like a zombie, a detail that, if real, matches the wounds on the victim. FBI Agent Ella Penrose heads the Paranormal Crimes Unit and handles cases that defy science and logic, and this one lands squarely on her desk. The strangeness only deepens as extinct beetles turn up, a severed arm surfaces belonging to a second victim, and another attack follows, leaving Ella and her partner, Holden, questioning everything they thought they knew. Meanwhile, the pair are fighting a personal battle, too: helping Ella’s relative Celest win parole for a killing that was self-defense—but someone is determined to keep her locked away. Berman’s debut novel blends the eerie mystery of The X-Files with the procedural rigor of CSI, and it succeeds on both fronts. The author spent years as a writer and producer on CSI, which shows in the book’s richly detailed forensic work, but he also understands when to hold back and let a mystery stay unexplained. Berman’s characters are sharp and memorable, and readers will be eager to see them in future installments.—Jeff Ayers
What do Blondie, Edgar Allan Poe, and Amontillado sherry have in common? These are all key to solving Zang’s atmospheric and creepy mystery. In 1985 Baltimore, sisters Annabel and Madeline (Mad) run Goldie’s, a dive bar with a Poe connection—it’s so like many southside bars, each with its own schtick. Their father not only named his daughters after Poe characters, he also is suspected of being the infamous Poe Toaster, who leaves roses and sherry at the grave on Poe’s death anniversary. After he disappears, a string of murders, all of bartenders, strikes the city. Before long, Mad is pulled into it, not knowing whom to suspect—Tim, who runs “spirit” tours around the city; Martin, a burly chef who takes a shine to her; or maybe even her own father. When she makes a gruesome discovery in a hidden room in the basement and Annabel is nowhere to be found, Mad knows she must do something to find her sister and protect herself, her cousin Piper, and Goldie’s. Zang cranks up the tension deliciously as more grisly connections are made, leaving Mad to come to a terrifyingly awful conclusion as to who is responsible for the killings. Poe and ‘final girl’ fans, this one’s for you!—Dodie Ownes
Book of the Week September 24, 2026
Between her controlling wife and the loss of her beloved stonemason job, Dorrie’s life feels empty—until ebullient Alys and her boyfriend move in next door. Chatting over the fence leads to clandestine outings to gardens and castles, and as their friendship grows, Dorrie begins to fall in love with Alys. When Alys leaves her boyfriend and returns to her childhood home, Dovecombe Manor, Dorrie sees this as the perfect escape. The manor turns out to be half burnt down and somewhat decrepit, sparking long-held anxieties for Dorrie. Why won’t Alys talk about the fire, and what are those figures in the woods? Add in a creepy housekeeper and her son; and Alys’s overbearing mother, Caroline, who wants to restore Dovecombe to its former glory, to complete the formula for this contemporary Gothic to ignite—literally and figuratively. Against the backdrop of small-town gossip and ancient folklore as well as Clark’s expansive knowledge of stonecutting, this atmospheric novel surrounds readers with a palpable sense of dread and malice.—Dodie Ownes
New York’s North Country is under siege from a drug crisis and a missing girl in Wegert’s gripping follow-up to In the Bones. You don’t need to have read the first book to get pulled straight into this mystery and its relentless, lights-on suspense. Police officer Tim Wellington has his hands full. A young man’s fatal overdose triggers a raid that nets a major drug seizure, but when lab results reveal that the seized drugs don’t match what killed him, Wellington and his team realize that a second, more dangerous supplier is flooding the area. Then, a young woman, barely dressed and moving like a zombie, bolts the instant she hears the word “police.” Not long after, another young woman, the daughter of a fellow officer, vanishes. What follows is a breathless race against time to find her and take down the dealer poisoning the community before the death toll climbs any higher. Wegert’s story is told through multiple perspectives, and the novel’s characters, heroes and villains alike, feel vividly real, grounding the story in an atmosphere that never rings false. The tension ratchets up with every chapter, making this a must-read for any thriller fan.—Jeff Ayers
In 1903 Oxford, Lilian “Lily” Delaney runs a bookbinding shop and bookstore with her business partner and mentor, John Caxton. At home, her boyfriend, Harry, wants to make things official and get married so they can stop pretending to be mere roommates, but Lily wants nothing to do with losing her identity, which is exactly what she fears will happen the moment she says yes to a ring. Then, a knock on the door sends Caxton spiraling: he closes the shop and disappears without explanation. Determined to find answers, Lily searches his office and uncovers a journal filled with coded messages. Deciphering them draws her into a web involving Caxton’s former colleagues; a legendary book, the Liber Numerorum (The Book of Numbers), which supposedly doesn’t even exist; and a ruthless man willing to kill for it. As Lily’s carefully built life unravels, her pursuit of the truth may cost her everything, including her life. Bell delivers a terrific follow-up to The Bookbinder’s Secret, unveiling another compelling mystery packed with codes, clues, and deception. What truly makes this series sing, though, is Lily herself, a fantastic character who would fit seamlessly into contemporary society. A woman with her talent, drive, and relentless pursuit of the truth in the early twentieth century has to fight twice as hard to solve the mystery and claim the life she wants. The rich glimpse into the world of bookbinding is a bonus to this outstanding book and great series.—Jeff Ayers
Celeste and Rory are enemies from the minute newcomer Celeste takes Rory’s spot on swim team in 7th grade. Now, they are about to graduate from high school and there has been no slowdown in them thinking about ways to hurt each other—while still being in the popular-kids friends group. A trip to Celeste’s family’s beach house sounds idyllic, until they both seek to up the ante. Secrets can be kept, but at what price? As misdeeds unfold against the background of a storm and power outage and mutual suspicion, the tension heightens and readers are left wondering who is telling the truth and who can be trusted. Blackmail? Yes. Teen angst? Yes. Musical chairs on the relationship front? Double yes! At the root is Celeste’s pastor father badly misbehaving, sabotaging her social status. What’s a girl to do? Clarke captures all the anxiety and self-doubt of not-quite-fully-cooked adults being thrust into the real world, with a wicked and surprising twist.—Dodie Ownes
Gigi and her sister Suzanna have left their small midwestern town behind for life in southern California, seeking sunshine and college degrees. To help make ends meet, Gigi takes a job as a server at The Black Cat, a high end gentlemen’s club, where she catches the eye of the owner’s nephew Dimitri—and the owner himself. When Gigi never makes it home following work one evening, the cops give it a pass. She’s been seen on camera at an ATM after all, and she calls Suzanna to tell her she’s fine. But her sister knows something is wrong. Enter Special Agent Emily Day, who has been focusing on missing persons, but has troubles of her own—she’s about to divorce and is attempting to leave the trauma of her job and past life behind. Then another girl from The Black Cat goes missing, and social media is blowing up—are there more? Dominguez Greene weaves in the war in Ukraine, Russian mobsters, dirty cops, border crossing and infertility seamlessly, giving each aspect the attention it deserves while keeping the momentum going. The Ninth Girl is an addictive, thrilling read with a social conscience that begs to be consumed in one sitting.—Dodie Ownes
