firstCLUE Reviews
  • Home
  • Review Database
  • Interviews
  • Crime Fiction News
  • Submission Guidelines
  • About Us
Tag:

Amateur Sleuth

Review

Murder By Design

by Jeff Ayers December 18, 2025

Edison Bixby was a great detective for the LAPD, and he knew it. When a brain injury forced him to resign, he became the best insurance investigator in the Los Angeles area. The injury has removed his social filter, magnifying his already massive ego to inappropriate proportions. Wally Nash gets by acting in commercials for medications that cure digestive problems, or playing corpses. Bixby’s insurance company hires him to watch over their wildcard investigator and to interpret or deflect anything he says that could be considered offensive. They are given a case involving what appears to be a woman simply falling to her death on a mall staircase. The video shows the victim alone when she took the tumble, so why does Bixby think it’s murder? Goldberg draws on his background in television to create this mismatched duo that echoes Monk and other mystery shows featuring a quirky, brilliant detective and a helpful sidekick. The sarcastic tone reflects the privilege and sense of importance many LA residents seem to exhibit, and the narrator routinely breaks the fourth wall, creating a book that is both hilarious and thought-provoking. The mystery itself is complex, and somehow Goldberg balances the humor and drama to perfection. The second book in this series cannot come fast enough, and hopefully a TV series is in the future as well.

December 18, 2025 0 comments
1 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

Last Night Was Killer

by Brian Kenney November 20, 2025

Book of The Week

Interested in a new and hilarious spin on motherhood? Then get on your reading list the laugh-aloud-funny/steer-wheel-gripping story of Tilly Turner, a single mom who will do anything for her identical twin daughters. When her career as a stand-up comic hits the shredder and her beloved mother has recently died, Tilly moves back to her hometown in Idaho, eager to establish community. Which, naturally, brings her to join a pole-dancing 101 class. And guess what? Pole dancing turns out to be a total blast. If only she didn’t wake up the next morning with a pounding headache, bad case of alcohol-induced amnesia, and a dead body scrunched in the trunk of the car. For starters, who is the dead man? Could Tilly have done him in? And where can she get a reliable babysitter whom the twins will love so that she can go figure out what’s happening and what the other strippers may know? Add to this the hottie agent from the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives who keeps showing up at her home, not invited but not disinvited either. Sit back, relax, and enjoy what is sure to be one of the best blends of crime fiction with a good dollop of coziness to be published in 2026.

© 2025 firstCLUE Reviews

Subscribe to our newsletter today!

November 20, 2025 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

The Dogwalkers’ Detective Agency

by Brian Kenney November 13, 2025

A heartfelt animal cozy akin to David Rosenfeld’s Andy Carpenter series and Rita Mae Brown’s Sneaky Pie Brown books, along with all the sophistication of Only Murders in the Building. The small, coastal town of Framstone is dog heaven, with walkers providing their pooches with rural strolls, treats galore, and smells most intriguing. Until Charles Boardman is dragged deep into the woods by Ruby, his Staffordshire bull terrier. Has Ruby found a half-eaten burger? Try the corpse of a former cop who now owns a bar. It takes only milliseconds for the information to spread among the dog-walking community, with mid-thirtyish Charlie—who grew up in Framstone and has only recently returned—at the center of the investigation. But the story doesn’t end there. Charlie receives anonymous threats, and, even more frightening, another body surfaces on the beach. Can Charlie resolve the mystery and come out alive? Hogan’s prose is delightful, full of humor and wonderfully clever. This reader’s only wish is that this book is the first in a series.

© 2025 firstCLUE Reviews

Subscribe to our newsletter today!

November 13, 2025 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

A Whiff of Murder

by Danise Hoover November 13, 2025

In a historic house in Astoria, OR lives Lise, who can scent emotion, and sometimes history; Fran, who can hear the spirits of the house talking; and Theodora, or Teddy, owner of the house and former muse to rock stars. The house itself accepts or rejects new renters, and though economics necessitates another housemate, the house so far has not found anyone acceptable. Lise, clerk in a shop that sells crystals, potions, tarot cards, and the like, finds her boss dead the morning after she submits her resignation, and the police officer who responds is a nemesis from her earlier years in Seattle. The three women, unsatisfied with the quick dismissal of the death as coming from natural causes, set out to find the truth. Their methods are creative, exciting, and somewhat dangerous. Our trio has intriguing backstories, and the adjunct characters that assist along the way are a wonderful addition to the cast. This is the first of a promised series from the author of another witchy Oregon series (the Witch Way Librarian books) and readers will look forward eagerly to the next installment.

© 2025 firstCLUE Reviews

Subscribe to our newsletter today!

November 13, 2025 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

The Murder at World’s End

by Willy Williams October 30, 2025

BOOK OF THE WEEK

Downton Abbey meets Gosford Park and Knives Out in this entertaining, locked-room historical cozy that marks best-selling British children’s author Montgomery’s (I am Rebel) successful foray into adult fiction. On May 18, 1910, Stephen Pike, fresh out of a Borstal Institution (a juvenile detention center), arrives at Tithe Hall on the Cornish tidal island of World’s End, where he has secured a job as an under-butler. But all is chaos at the manor as Lord Conrad Stockingham-Welt prepares to seal all the windows, doors, and keyholes of Tithe Hall from the dangerous gases that he believes the approaching Halley’s Comet will bring. Assigned to care for Conrad’s octogenarian aunt, Stephen spends the evening outside observing the comet with the scientifically inclined but foul-tempered and foul-mouthed Miss Decima Stockingham. Fortunately, she proves to be Stephen’s alibi when the hall’s rooms are unsealed the next morning and her nephew is found dead in his study, shot through the eye with a crossbow. Determined to identify the murderer with methodical rigor, Decima enlists Stephen’s assistance in investigating possible suspects among the family, guests, and staff. Was it cousin Edwin Welt, MP, who expects to inherit the estate? Or another cousin, Lettice Welt, rumored to have had a hand in the untimely demise (from gastric flu) of her husband, daughter, and son-in-law? Or could it even be the butler, Mr. Stokes, with his own secrets? The eccentric, hilarious Decima and the naive Stephen, who grows in self-confidence, make a delightful sleuthing pair as they track clues and cross names off their list of suspects. Cozy historical fans will anticipate the dynamic duo’s next adventure.

© 2025 firstCLUE Reviews
Sign up for our FREE newsletter!

 

October 30, 2025 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

Robbie McNeil’s Hit List.

by Danise Hoover October 30, 2025

A characteristic that makes mysteries such a popular genre is that the concept of right and wrong is so often very clear. Not so much here. Robbie, our heroine, and Dee, her queerplatonic partner in a gay karaoke bar in a nothing Indiana town, are both successful contract killers. Their jobs are done quickly, cleanly, and without emotion, except for Robbie’s latest one. The information on the local target is sketchy and the target himself suddenly disappears. She can’t afford to return the deposit because she and Robbie have sunk all their money into a theatrical venture, and besides, it feels all wrong. Instead of ignoring who the target is, she works hard to find out the exact opposite. We have local politicians, Robbie’s musical ambitions, and the lively karaoke scene all tangled up with a client who just won’t quit in his effort to have this target done away with. Heath provides a fun story with a great deal of gender and identity fluidity. There is a happy ending of sorts, but is it right?

October 30, 2025 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

Three Bengal Kittens

by Brian Kenney October 30, 2025

An absolute joy from start to finish. In this fourth book in the series, veterinarian Peter Bannerman finds his brother Sam living in a Winnipeg apartment house, with a dead neighbor whom the cops believe has passed on as a result of accidental autoerotic asphyxiation. But once the cops have hauled Sam in for questioning, their focus shifts, and he is eventually arrested for the murder. Sam has more than his share of mental health issues, and having him as a brother is challenging to say the least. For starters, Sam’s more concerned with finding one of the kittens who has gone lost—it belongs to his dead neighbor—than finding the real criminal and maybe springing himself from jail. But, luckily, Sam has Peter, who may be incredibly frustrated by his brother, but is certain that he would never hurt anyone, beast or human. Unfortunately, it becomes Peter’s job to prove to the cops Sam’s innocence, discover the murderer, and locate the missing kitten. Fortunately, he has assistance from Pippin, his dog and a Western Canadian champion sniffer; and his wife Laura, who provides Peter with some useful critical thinking. In the end, we are taken down a path rife with ghosts and murderers and that resolves the past by investigating the present.

October 30, 2025 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

The Midnight Taxi

by Danise Hoover October 23, 2025

Book of the Week

Driving a taxi is often the first job for a new immigrant, as it was for the father of Siriwathi, or Siri, as her friends call her. She drives the cab now as a family obligation. A brown woman doing this job late at night is not exactly ideal or safe, nor is it what she planned to do with her life. At the court building in lower Manhattan, she fortuitously picks up a fare: another brown woman, another Sri Lankan, a public defender. In the short time it takes to drive to Brooklyn, they bond somewhat. That’s good, because Siri’s next fare, one to JFK airport, is dead on arrival. Siri is arrested and really needs a lawyer; Alex, a wealthy friend from private-school days (Siri was a scholarship student) helps bail her out, and he and the two women do a deep investigation into the victim, finding more than any run-of-the-mill police inquiry would. This is an ultra-complicated story, but what makes it special is a view of immigrant New York that few see. Deep family ties, strong food culture, and love and longing for a better future build a picture that one can only hope isn’t quashed by today’s political chaos.

October 23, 2025 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

Murder Will Out

by Danise Hoover October 9, 2025

In this sparkling, energetic debut, we have a murder to be solved, not just for the benefit of the community, but for the health and well-being of the ghosts that abide within the Cameron family mansion that is under contention. Willow, graduate music student and accomplished organist, receives an invitation from her long-estranged godmother, Sue, to attend her wedding. The message was written long before it was sent. Sue is now dead, and Willow makes it to the funeral with just enough time to play Sue’s favorite music. Maine’s Little North Island is where she spent her summers with Sue until her parents summarily ended the arrangement with no explanation. Sue had come out as a lesbian to Willow’s parents, which they found abhorrent. After the service, the next Cameron heir is poisoned, and Willow, along with a tight group of local women, set out to unearth the truth. Her own top-notch research skills pale in comparison to those of the village librarian, who unearths essential old family facts. This is a wonderfully tangled plot, and the characters are aided in the solving by a fantastic range of ghosts. It is oh-so-much fun and leaves open the possibility of another to come.

October 9, 2025 0 comments
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Review

The Pie & Mash Detective Agency

by Jeff Ayers October 2, 2025

Book of the Week

What does a dating millennial couple do to add adventure to their lives? Take a class on becoming a private detective, of course! Jane Pye and Simon Mash are quirky; even their class instructor finds them a bit strange. With no job possibilities anywhere in their immediate futures, they decide to open the Pie & Mash Detective Agency after they graduate. Then they are given a class assignment that the instructor guarantees will result in a failing grade. Dev Hooper’s girlfriend, Nellie Thorne, has vanished. The police believe she’s just left him, but Dev thinks otherwise. As Jane and Simon start investigating, they stumble upon what’s either a wild coincidence or something more sinister. This Nellie Thorne is not the first woman with her name to vanish; the phenomenon has been occurring for decades. All of the women are similar in appearance, and all disappeared after around a year of dating. Is this a weird legend or ghosts? If it’s real, are others with that name safe? J.D. Brinkworth is the writing team of Jo Dinkin and Catherine Brinkworth, and this quirky, fun mystery will keep readers guessing while bringing a smile to their faces. The main characters are a hoot, and a hodgepodge of strange folks with secret agendas surrounds them. Filled with British humor, this introduction to Jane and Simon is hopefully the start of a long series. (DEBUT)

October 2, 2025 0 comments
1 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • …
  • 21

Subscribe to the firstCLUE Reviews newsletter published weekly on Thursday, for our reviews of the newest in adult and YA crime fiction!

Subscribe Now

Recent Posts

  • Consider the Ravens
  • Murder at the Lonely Gnome Bookshop
  • Someone Saved My Life Tonight
  • Cold Dark Deep
  • Gideon’s Ring

Recent Comments

No comments to show.
  • Bluesky
  • Instagram
  • Email

©Copyright 2024, firstCLUE - All Right Reserved.


Back To Top
firstCLUE Reviews
  • Home
  • Review Database
  • Interviews
  • Crime Fiction News
  • Submission Guidelines
  • About Us