Rose Dearling’s brother, Will, sits in jail, convicted of murdering Alexandria Hopely, his first love. With adjoining backyards, the Dearling and the Hopely families were particularly close, but that all changed when Rose refused to accept that Will was the killer. Years later, Rose is the best-selling author of The Smileys Next Door, a thinly fictionalized account of what she thinks really happened to Alex, naming Mr. Hopely as his daughter’s murderer. When her sister, Hazel, disappears, Rose is summoned by family to leave New York City and return to her hometown, Loxahatchee FL, where unsurprisingly, former friends regard her with suspicion and disdain. As family secrets begin to surface, Rose becomes even more convinced that Will is innocent and that the real killer is still on the loose. Local cop Nick Pullman gets put on the case, bringing another backstory into the narrative as the search for Hazel grows more desperate. A skanky teacher and a lecherous neighbor round out the cast, and Hanks has readers’ heads snapping as this story tumults to its thrilling and surprising conclusion.—Dodie Ownes
Domestic
Book of the Week April 23, 20226
Nadeeka leaves work early, convinced that her boyfriend, Jamie, is cheating and determined to confront him. Instead, she arrives home to flashing lights, police tape, and the devastating news that Jamie has been stabbed to death in their living room. What begins as a search for his possible lover quickly spirals into something far more unsettling. As Nadeeka digs deeper, nothing about Jamie’s life lines up with the man she thought she knew. His coworkers insist her name is Nadia—the name he used for her. A cherished photo of the two of them is hidden away in a drawer rather than displayed. And then comes the most shocking revelation of all: Jamie’s ties to a white supremacist group called New Dawn, including his role in a local arson. The betrayal Nadeeka feared turns out to be the least of it. With each discovery, the ground beneath her shifts, pulling her into a reality that feels increasingly unreal. Mackintosh crafts a chilling, emotionally grounded thriller that continually upends expectations. Packed with sharp twists and a deeply sympathetic protagonist, It’s Not What You Think lives up to its title in every way, delivering a story that will keep even seasoned thriller readers guessing until the very end.—Jeff Ayers
Jessie and her husband, Vaughn, are divorcing. Living on opposite coasts and struggling to determine custody for their nine-year-old son, Dylan, they agree to have Dylan fly solo from LA to New York to visit Vaughn. The airline has is ready to accommodate him as an unaccompanied minor, and it’s all set for his grandparents to pick him up when he lands. With an AirTag in his backpack and location sharing on both his phone and watch, he takes off. Hours later at JFK, his grandparents tell Jessie they were diverted to another gate to pick him up, but it turns out the plane landed at the correct one. At the gate where Dylan landed, people who look like his grandparents pick him up and have the proper paperwork. When Jessie checks, the AirTag says he’s still in LA, but the tracking on his phone and watch say he’s still at the gate. Who would want to take Dylan? At the same time, a subway operator in Toronto sees green lights all the way to the next station and slams into a stationary car. The operator’s last words are, “The lights were green,” but the video footage shows only red lights. And this is only the beginning of this intense and fantastic thriller. Mofina’s compelling and twisty narrative builds suspense while playing with reader expectations. He takes a great plot and adds the human element so we care about the characters and what’s happening on every gripping page. Everyone should be one second away from snapping this up and adding it to their reading pile.—Jeff Ayers
Linden and Verity Lockwood appear to have the perfect life—a successful business together, a lovely home, and an active social life. Verity’s closest friend, her cousin Addison, works with her, and she has a small circle of women that she is close to. Though her mother is distant, she hopes to repair that soon. And Linden—well, sometimes he can seem obsessive about things, but that’s just his nature. Everything shifts when Verity is away at a yoga retreat to promote the Verity Rose brand and Linden is brutally murdered. Shattered, she returns to work, but moves out of Windermere, the home they shared, and starts to put her life back together, only to find out, a year after Linden’s death, that he had been having an affair. The police are lost as to a motive and suspects, but Verity wants justice so starts to put the pieces together herself. Then her friend Mimi disappears, stoking even more suspicion. Told in alternating chapters of The Wife and The Other Woman, this domestic thriller is packed with lots of juicy twists and turns, and SO MANY LIES! The slow unraveling of the mystery surrounding despicable Linden’s death will have readers suspecting virtually every one in Verity’s circle.—Dodie Ownes
Eastbrook is the Right Kind of Town with the Right Kind of People. The parents are dual-income DC professionals, the kids are off to Georgetown and Princeton, and it’s graduation season, when everything is “just so.” Nobody wants blow-in Finn to keep papering local lampposts with flyers about the nanny who was shot dead in Eastbrook last summer. Ancient history, best forgotten, right? But things start to come further apart at the seams when a local mom, Caren, collapses on the way home from a block party. The next day, she can’t remember where she spent the night and has an injury to the back of her head. That story alternates with that of Tori, who’s new to the town and struggling to adjust. Local teen behaviors make their way in, too, with all combining to give a stealthy look at domestic turmoil and what rich people find important, with their priorities and desperation hit by twists more than once. Thompson’s spot-on language and characterization puts the suburbs under a microscope and will leave readers wanting more.—Henrietta Thornton
A group of sorority sisters gets together to celebrate queen bee Roxy’s son’s engagement to Celeste, the daughter of her Theta Mu sister Beth—or at least that’s what the event appears to be on the surface. But there is something odd about the estate, recently renovated by Roxy’s husband, Ryan, that reminds them all of the tragedy that happened many years ago during spring break, when their sorority sister Sunny was found dead in the pool at the Desert Inn. Nothing about these “sisters” is what it seems, and all have their own stories about the night that Sunny died. Rouda packs a lot of drama into the slow unraveling of the characters—the successful doctor, the Beltway not-really-grieving widow, the scholarship girl, the victim, the drug dealer—until the real crime comes into view. Including a ghost seems like cheating, but the woman in a green gown who looks just like Sunny cannot be an apparition, can she? Mean Girls has nothing on We Were Never Friends.
© 2025 firstCLUE Reviews
Subscribe to our newsletter today!
![]()
Yes, it’s ridiculously early. But I’m ready to crown The Summer House Murder the most toxic family novel of 2026. Venom, backstabbing, competitiveness, lies, jealousy, greed, out-and-out hatred all come together to create their own totally riveting little house of horrors. At the center are three sisters—Esme, Piper, and Regina—who are off to Lake George, and their now deceased parent’s cottage, for their annual shared vacation. With three immensely different characters at work, it only takes a few drinks for the women to quickly point out one anothers’ faults, from not cleaning the kitchen to mishandling infidelity to, I kid you not, child abduction. As if that weren’t enough, how about a murder, with a direct connection to the three sisters? I loved this book, but more importantly, so will you. The perfect summer read.
Tavish Advani has found an idyllic new life. He’s newly arrived in New Zealand, having eagerly left Los Angeles to live with the love of his life, Diya Prasad, in her home country. But Tavish can’t leave behind a dogged LA cop’s suspicion that he caused the deaths of several women he was involved with there. When a fire consumes the lavish home he lives in with Diya and her wealthy doctor parents, is he responsible? The savvy local police officer assigned to the case thinks so. Case notes by that officer and the LA cop who still suspects Tavish of murder are sprinkled throughout the story of the young man’s desperate efforts to clear his name and will lead readers to think that the legal picture doesn’t look so good for him. But as the details of Diya’s earlier life with her family and their friends unspools, a toxicity emerges that makes things far less clear cut. A suffocating family is perfectly drawn here, and Tavish’s early life has its own surprises; with the brilliant twists bestselling Singh drops in, it all adds up to a gripping tale.
Through the alternating viewpoints of the newlyweds and someone who’s watching them, we follow the unhappy Paris honeymoon of Olivier and Cassie and the time before and after it. Olivier’s time in Paris is a reluctant trip home, given that his tenuous immigration status means that he shouldn’t have left the U.S. But spoiled Cassie, who seems mainly to enjoy the trip as a chance to look glamorous on Instagram, insisted. What Cassie wants, Cassie gets, especially since their marriage is Olivier’s ticket to a life outside France and his gigantic debts there. The person following their every move and Cassie’s every social-media post can see that things aren’t as perfect as Cassie would have her followers believe and delights in the obvious discord. This look at the Paris sojourn alternates with the story of the couple’s short time dating and the aftermath of their immigration-fueled decision to wed, when they live with Cassie’s sister in the family’s former inn. It’s far from the cozy getaway spot and possible moneymaker that Cassie described, adding to the feeling that both parties here have been had. The crime-filled ending of the honeymoon, a twist readers won’t see coming, and life back home deliver on the promise of the increasingly dark relationship and save tantalizing reveals until the very end. Try The Paris Apartment while you wait for this absorbing thriller.
When Isla’s shady side business of digging up dirt for hire leads her back to the all-too-familiar Corrigan Group, she must face the demons this powerful family has held over her for the past 10 years. Isla had a tough start to life, orphaned young and stumbling through her formative years until she met Eden Galloway and finally felt like she had found her family. At 16, Isla and Eden’s plan to run away is interrupted by Eden’s insistence on resolving her mysterious unfinished business with the Corrigan family in Virginia. Promising to return before Isla wakes up the next day, Eden is never seen again. And since Isla is an unhoused 16 year old running from the threat of foster care, she has no option but to keep moving. Isla never forgot about her friend, she just never had a way in—until now. As Isla digs deeper into the Corrigans, she finds unlikely friends and even stronger enemies working their own agendas within the powerful family. Isla must push through the network of lies and family loyalties in order to discover the only truth she really cares about: what happened to Eden? Find yourself as a fly on the wall in the home of this power-hungry, treacherous, and deceitful family as all of their secrets come to light in one final stand-off.
